My 5 Favorite Pairs of Comfortable Underwear | The Lingerie Addict: Helping You Find The Lingerie of Your Dreams!
Tla Logo

Inclusivity matters in lingerie too!
Enter your email below to discover our Top 20 Lingerie Brands (and get a free chapter of my book!):

We promise to never send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

Looking for the Perfect Lingerie Guide? Signed Copies of In Intimate Detail are Now Available!

Order Your Copy Today!

Signed Copies of In Intimate Detail: How to Choose, Wear, and Love Lingerie are available now! Click here!

My 5 Favorite Pairs of Comfortable Underwear

I've talked comfy panties on TLA a couple of times before, but now that it's been a little over two years since the last article, I believe it's time for a revisit. The topic of comfortable underwear is one I feel very passionate about. Especially when we're talking everyday/go to work/run errand knickers, if it's not, at bare minimum, so comfortable you forget you're wearing it, what's the point? There's nothing worse than constantly needing to pull, tug, and readjust your underpants just to get through your day. Before I started writing this blog, I hated panty shopping. Everything was too tight or too low and just generally awful. It took buying custom panties from On The Inside to discover my love of underwear. But now, nearly a decade later, I have another set of lingerie concerns.

About a year or so ago, I was diagnosed with vulvodynia, which is a type of chronic nerve pain affecting the vulva. While my particular form of vulvodynia comes and goes, it can be easily triggered by wearing uncomfortable underwear. Something as simple as a raised seam, a cheap synthetic fiber blend, or even a harsh detergent is all it takes to trigger a flareup, leaving me housebound and nearly bedridden for a week or more. After I was diagnosed and once I realized this was going to be a ongoing issue, I actually stopped accepting items for product reviews because I simply cannot wear certain things anymore.

Being diagnosed with vulvodynia completely changed the way I think about underwear. Pantylines, shaping briefs, even matching sets... all of that pales in comparison to the importance of finding underwear that won't leave me in abject misery. Now I look for natural fibers, soft fabrics, and avoid anything with the word "cheeky" in the name. While obviously my condition is a special case, if these knickers are comfortable for me, there's a chance they'll be comfortable for you too. These are the brands I personally wear everyday, and I'm happy enough with them all to recommend them. Now let's talk comfy drawers!

Egretta Garzetta Floral High Waist Brief - $25.00

Egretta Garzetta Floral High Waist Brief - $25.00

Available in sizes XS-XL with the additional option of custom sizing, Egretta Garzetta's vivid prints made underwear exciting for me again. I own about five pairs of her high waist briefs right now (in other prints like this one as well as plain colors like heather grey), and I love them. The panties are made of 95-96% viscose with 4-5% lycra (depending on style) and have a 100% cotton crotch. They also hold up very well to machine washing. If you're looking to buy a few at a time, Egretta Garzetta offers a discount for ordering multiple pairs. Just drop her a line and ask about it. Quick note though (and this is especially true if you're buying custom), give her a few days to put your order together. You're looking at about 1-2 weeks to ship, and another 2-3 weeks to receive from Latvia.

I first learned about Marianna Giordana through her beautiful lace pieces, but I fell in love with the brand after buying the classic style briefs shown here. These floral print knickers are 100% cotton, and available in sizes XS-XL, though custom is also an option. Technically, these panties are part of Marianne Giordana's diffusion, Petale de Fleur, which features camis, leggings, and similar, but you can purchase from either store. Made to order items require about a two-week turnaround, but in-stock items are shipped within 5 days from France.

When I was first diagnosed with vulvodynia, I was unable to wear most of my underwear. A lot of brands that were extremely comfortable before became completely intolerable in my new state. Fortunately, Cheek Frills had just sent over their Days of the Week panty set and these saved my lingerie life. When you're hypersensitive, soft fabric counts for everything, and as I mentioned in an earlier review of the brand, their fabric is unbelievably soft. I can't even describe how wonderful these feel against the skin. Made of 95% modal and 5% elastane, these panties are available in sizes S-L. The care instructions say to handwash, which would be best for the high quality nature of this fabric, but you can also wash in a lingerie bag on delicate cycle (preferably alone or with a very small number of similar items).

After reading Rose's review of Play Out, I knew I had to try these, and I was not disappointed. The fabric is a delightful-to-the-touch micromodal/cotton/spandex blend, and I love how the cut, color, and print on these is less femme than my usual underwear. I would say that if you have issues with vulval pain, you may want to size up on these (they tend to get a bit cheeky on me), but you could opt for the trunks cut, which has more room in the genital area (when I'm having a flare-up, mens' boxer briefs are all I wear). On a fashion-related note, when Play Out's prints sell out, they're gone. So if you see something you like, pick it up right away (because I really wish I had a pair of their purple star boxer briefs). Editor's Note: I was wrong! They're back in stock on Play Out's site here.  Sizes are S-XL, and you can machine wash these on delicate cycle.

PACT Tropical Hipster - $16.00

PACT Tropical Hipster - $16.00

The most recent addition to the comfy panty collection, this PACT Tropical Hipster is already in my regular rotation. I also own the more pink-toned Butterfly Hipster, but I found this particular colorway to fit a bit better. If Fair Trade Certification and non-GMO fibers are important to you, PACT uses both, and the panty is 95% organic cotton/5% elastane. Lately, I've taken to wearing these whenever I travel. (Editor's Note: Unfortunately, the pair shown above is no longer available.)

A couple of final notes: I wore a size Large in everything listed here. I also machine wash everything shown here, but on the delicate cycle with cold water and a lingerie wash bag. If you suffer from sensitivity, using a mild, unscented lingerie wash is best (don't use a "regular" detergent or anything with additives). If that's not an option, try baking soda. With the exception of Shopbop (where the Cheek Frills 'Days of the Week' knickers are), I've bought from all the shops linked here as well and been happy with them.

What's your favorite brand for comfy panties? Any advice for those who are frustrated by knickers shopping?


Cora Harrington

Founder and Editor in Chief of The Lingerie Addict. Author of In Intimate Detail: How to Choose, Wear, and Love Lingerie. I believe lingerie is fashion too, and that everyone who wants it deserves gorgeous lingerie.

12 Comments on this post

  1. Nicola says:

    Do you have a go to silk or organic silk brand for panties? I’ve been searching for the perfect silk panties ever since I read your post about silk on twitter years ago.

  2. I have vulvodynia, too, and don’t wear underwear in daily life. But, I just found these to be amazingly comfortable and sexy. The underwear looks good and fits well for a larger butt because of the cut overlap in back. The crotch is not there so no vulvar pain from it itself. I haven’t worn these under pants – because I can’t wear pants due to the vulva – so I can’t comment, but they look and feel good for everyday. Nothing cuts into you to make you unhappy.


  3. a says:

    When you post these lists, I keep hoping that you’ll say something about Intertwined Designs, even if it’s bad so I can just cross them off my list. I’ve been wanting to try their soy/cotton boy shorts or underwear since it seems like they’d be soft and comfortable, but the only reviews I’ve seen are on the short purchase reviews on Etsy. The price with shipping from Washington is just a bit too high for me right now just to go by those reviews. Have you heard anything about them locally?

  4. Emma says:

    Thanks for this list! Have wanted to try Egretta Garzetta for a while and must do that soon. Otherwise my most comfortable panties are from Made by Noemi’s classic line :)

  5. Dee says:

    I turn to Lane Bryant’s cotton plus sized boy shorts for most of my daily wear undies, as they are pretty darn comfy! They’re a bit bulky in the croch for the first few wears (four peices of fabric meeting up down there! covered by a panel of cotton gusset), but that goes away after a bit and then they’re pretty good, and the lace around the top is a nice touch on a fairly utilitarian garment.

  6. Trish says:

    I just tried Cheek Frills and I’m in love! I also like Foxer’s boxers for sleep.

  7. Melissa29 says:

    I will have to try the Garzetta’s. I love the prints. So far I love the Hanky Panky underwear. They are very comfortable for me.

  8. TJ says:

    I’m in love with the fabric in the Marianne Giordana panties! It’s more botanical than florals tends to be.

  9. S.B says:

    I know that everyone probably says this, but the cotton bliss panties by Natori are my go to. I have never owned panties so comfortable. They’re soft, light, breathable and they come in pretty much any color of the rainbow.

    • Cora says:

      I know exactly what you mean! They were in a previous post on comfy panties, and I agree. Those and my Between the Sheets boyshorts have a permanent place in the Comfy Panty Hall of Fame.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *